Gregory Scott Witherspoon, Mile High Murder No. 84: Man charged in bathtub incident that took baby’s life nine months later

The case against Gregory Scott Witherspoon, 27, hasn’t moved quickly. Instead, it’s been a slow-motion horror show. The tragedy began on June 27, 2009, when six-month-old Ci’Area Taylor-Witherspoon was transported to a hospital. Her father, Gregory, told police he’d left Ci’Area in the bathtub with her two-year-old brother, and when…

Abby Toll convicted of taping a dog upside-down to a refrigerator

Last month, we told you about a case involving Abby Toll, who was told she couldn’t offer a mental-impairment claim as a defense against a bizarre animal cruelty charge: She was accused of affixing her boyfriend’s dog upside-down to a refrigerator using packing tape and hair bands. That ruling pretty…

Elizabeth “Libby” Santaguida, Mile High Murder No. 82: Bizarre affidavit, Facebook tributes to woman whose brother, Zachariah, has been charged with killing her

On Friday, we told you about the arrest of Zachariah Thomas Santaguida, eighteen, in the death of his 24-year-old sister, subsequently identified as Elizabeth “Libby” Santaguida. Libby’s Facebook page has turned into a de facto memorial site, with plenty of friends and family members adding their thoughts to a profile…

Alfred Luedtke has sword, will threaten — until the cops tase him

Anyone can threaten people with a gun. People who do that are as common as Caucasians at Tea Party rallies. But Alfred Luedtke, 42, is allegedly a cut above. This weekend, according to the Colorado Springs Police Department, officers arrived at Luedtke’s residence after hearing reports that he had threatened…

Sleepover Stu: Shmuck of the Week

For the Drunken Horny Man, women do have a tendency to blend together, especially when that man is young and unpolished in the arena of managing his drunken woman-chasing. But still, Stu. You gotta stay in the right bed. As Michael Roberts reported on Monday, a young woman recently had…

Limping Latex Bandit has premature explosion in his car

Update, 4:32 p.m.: Just notified by the Douglas County Sheriff’s Office that Merle Allison, who’s believed to be the Limping Latex Bandit, has been captured. Look below the original item to get all the details. As the number of Denver area robberies continue to capture the imagination of TV news…

Pigs tied up, beaten at historic farm

Stories of animal abuse don’t get much stranger or more disgusting that the one involving two pigs at Venetucci Farm, a 190-acre spread near Colorado Springs that was donated to the Pikes Peak Community Foundation in 2006. According to Lieutenant Lari Sevene, public information officer for the El Paso Sheriff’s…

Dustin Winesberry, registered sex offender, takes world’s sexiest mug shot

Words commonly used to describe mug shots include “menacing,” “pathetic,” “disturbing” and “hilarious” — but usually not “sexy.” So congrats, Dustin Winesberry. The seductive, come-hither mug shot taken of you yesterday at Boulder County Jail looks like the cover of a ’70s-era album — say, Dustin Winesberry Gets Next to…

Dan Tang sentencing in Operation Fortune Cookie makes “absolutely no sense,” says Tom Gorman, drug task force head

The drama continues around Operation Fortune Cookie, the largest weed bust in state history, which imploded amid accusations of snitching cops, paid-off politicians and bureaucratic retribution. Last week, the drug investigation’s main suspect, politically connected restaurateur Dan Tang, received eighteen months in prison for a single money laundering charge he…